AdvertiseDonate
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Local news for Davidson County, Tennessee.
Davidson County Herald · 21 Platform Way S, 14th Floor, Nashville, TN 37203

New Knesset Bill Sets 220-Convert Threshold for Jewish Status

Otzma Yehudit MP Limor Son Har-Melech introduced a draft on Monday that restricts Law of Return eligibility to halachic conversions, a change that would override the 2021 Dahan ruling.

By Mia Bennett ·

Illustration for: New Knesset Bill Sets 220-Convert Threshold for Jewish Status
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Otzma Yehudit party member Limor Son Har-Melech submitted a bill to the 26th Knesset on Monday. The draft, filed two days after the new parliament was sworn in, proposes a change to Israel's Law of Return. The text limits state recognition of Jewish conversions to those performed strictly according to halacha.

The proposal seeks to overturn the Dahan ruling issued by the High Court of Justice in 2021. That decision required the state to recognize Reform and Conservative conversions performed in Israel for immigration and population registration purposes. The court at the time described the issue as civil rather than religious. The new legislation would impose a religious standard that effectively nullifies that prior ruling.

The bill redefines the legal status of a Jew as a person born to a Jewish mother who does not belong to another religion, or a person who converted according to halacha. The draft does not define what constitutes a halachic conversion. It leaves unresolved which authority, the Chief Rabbinate or private Orthodox courts, determines compliance. Private Orthodox groups such as Giyur K'Halacha convert approximately 220 people per year. This figure is comparable to the Reform movement's annual total of 234 and higher than the Conservative movement's 92.

The change would alter the status of conversions performed abroad. The High Court has recognized Diaspora Reform and Conservative conversions for registry purposes since the late 1980s. An analysis by the Israel Democracy Institute indicates the new bill would remove aliyah eligibility for those who converted overseas. This shift is notable given Pew Research Center data showing that 37% of Jewish adults in the United States identify as Reform and 17% as Conservative, while only 9% identify as Orthodox.

Lawmakers have historically avoided adding the phrase "according to halacha" to the Law of Return. Following the 1970 Shalit ruling, the Knesset included a definition of a Jew but deliberately left out that specific wording to maintain ties with Diaspora Jewry. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blocked an identical proposal from MK Simcha Rothman in the final days of the previous Knesset. He cited concerns about the reaction from the Jewish diaspora.

The draft does not repeal the grandchild clause. Individuals with a Jewish grandparent can still immigrate as family members, though they would not be registered as Jewish. Those who underwent non-Orthodox conversions and lack other qualifying relatives could lose their right to immigrate. The Dahan ruling affected a relatively small group, averaging about 326 Reform and Conservative converts annually in Israel. This is a fraction of the thousands who convert through state or military systems.

Supporters argue the bill prevents the state from recognizing individuals as Jewish who cannot marry or be buried under Chief Rabbinate rules. MK Simcha Rothman stated the intention is not to harm liberal Judaism but to prevent fictitious or lenient conversions conducted specifically for immigration purposes.

More Politics · World news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Davidson County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Davidson County, Tennessee. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Davidson County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Davidson County, Tennessee. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.